Friday, September 28, 2007

Palm Reading

Look, I'm a pretty big fan of Apple's technology. I have a Newton and a stash of six color logo stickers. My first Mac was beige, and it's name didn't start with an i. Regardless of what loyalties these facts might imply, the phone I'm interested in doesn't have an i in its name either. It's the Palm Centro.

[image from Gizmodo]

The Centro is an easy enough phone to disregard, especially if you're under the impression (like I was) that it runs Windows Mobile (it doesn't). I don't know anyone who has nice things to say about WinMobile, although I'm sure there are some masochists out there who do. It is an Astro Van of an operating system that tries to cram its retrofitted self into a space intended for compact cars. PalmOS, on the other hand, is well tailored for the devices it runs on. It also has the added bonus of being the only platform the game 'Space Trader' supports.

I've been extremely pleased with the performance of my Palm Treo 650 (and not just because my prior phone was a Sony Ericsson). Here's what I like about it:
  • QWERTY keyboard
  • Threaded SMS conversations
  • Nice OS - intuitive and rock solid
  • I can hear the people I talk to, they can hear me
  • Touchscreen (the color is also a bonus)
  • Bluetooth (I use it for syncing, not with a headset)
  • Full-size SD slot
  • Mute on/off slider on the top of the phone
  • Awesome battery life
  • Space Trader (of course), SSH, and a whole slew of other third party applications
Here's what I don't like about the Treo 650:
  • The web browser is kind of crappy (although Universe 3 seems like a viable solution)
  • The default sync software for OS X is also somewhat crappy (I use Missing Sync)
  • No Graffiti
The Treo's a chunky phone, and I do appreciate when I can use my gadgets as weapons in street fighting, but there's also something to be said for phones that can comfortably fit in pockets. Hence my interest in upgrading to the slimmer Centro. The only things I'd really be losing are weight, a full-size SD slot, and a visible antenna.

Why not an iPhone? Well, the lovely web browser, decent data plan, and impeccable design are not enough. It's not that I don't want to switch carriers — I'm already on AT&T.

The iPhone is a 1.0 product, not to mention Apple's first real foray into the cellular market (the sorry implementation of iTunes on Motorola's ROKR doesn't count). I am quite happy to let the 1 million (and counting) beta testers who bought the iPhone identify the device's flaws, and give Apple the time to fix the problems. I often have the capacity to be a patient woman, and in the case of the problematic iPhone 1.1.1 firmware update, it seems to have paid off.

The Centro has a microSD slot as well, so when Moore's Law kicks into high gear, capacity beyond 8GB is feasible. No tactile Bluetooth QWERTY keyboard has a design that does the iPhone justice, while the Centro has keyboard buttons built in.

The iPhone also costs $399 — nearly four times the cost of the $99 Centro (although I expect the price will drop further by the time Centros are available on AT&T). I like bargains.

No comments: